Columbus Nursing Homes: Complete 2025 Guide to Finding Quality Care
Expert analysis of Columbus's 31 nursing homes. With only 23% rated 4-5 stars, Columbus families need to be selective - this guide helps you find the quality options in Ohio's capital.
Columbus at a Glance
Total Facilities
31 nursing homes
Average Rating
2.6 stars
Daily Cost (Semi-Private)
$315/day
$9,589/month • 3% above national average
High-Quality Facilities (4-5 Stars)
7 facilities (23%)
6 five-star, 1 four-star
Columbus Nursing Home Overview
Columbus, Ohio's capital and largest city with 902,000 residents, offers 31 nursing homes serving a senior population of 96,905 residents aged 65 and older. While Columbus leads Ohio in economic growth, innovation, and healthcare infrastructure, the nursing home market lags behind what you'd expect from a major state capital.
The Columbus Reality:
- • Only 7 facilities (23%) have 4-5 stars
- • 16 facilities (52%) are rated just 2 stars
- • 65% of facilities have 2 stars or below
- • Families must be highly selective to find quality care
This doesn't mean quality care doesn't exist in Columbus - it absolutely does. Six five-star facilities provide excellent care, and Ohio State University's medical infrastructure supports good clinical outcomes. But unlike markets like Jacksonville (62% with 4-5 stars) or Phoenix (42% with 4-5 stars), Columbus families can't be casual about facility selection.
The good news: Columbus costs are reasonable ($315/day, only 3% above the national average), and the city's six five-star facilities offer strong options if you prioritize them in your search. This guide will help you navigate Columbus's nursing home market and find the quality care your loved one deserves.
The Quality Reality: Why Columbus is Challenging
Understanding why Columbus struggles with nursing home quality helps families make informed decisions and set realistic expectations:
1. Ohio's Statewide Quality Challenges
Columbus reflects broader challenges across Ohio:
- •Ohio ranks in the bottom third nationally for nursing home quality
- •Lower Medicaid reimbursement rates make it harder for facilities to invest in quality
- •Healthcare workforce shortages are more severe than coastal states
- •Rural areas pull down state averages, but Columbus itself hasn't escaped these trends
2. Staffing and Turnover Issues
Columbus nursing homes face persistent staffing challenges:
- •Competitive labor market - nurses can earn more at Ohio State Wexner Medical Center or Nationwide Children's Hospital
- •High turnover rates reduce continuity of care and quality outcomes
- •Lower nursing home wages (compared to hospitals) create recruitment difficulties
3. Older Facility Infrastructure
Many Columbus nursing homes were built decades ago and struggle with:
- •Outdated physical plants that don't meet modern standards
- •Semi-private rooms (2-4 residents per room) instead of private rooms
- •Limited rehabilitation space and therapy amenities
- •Institutional feel rather than home-like environments
4. Market Consolidation and Corporate Ownership
Large chains own many Columbus facilities, and corporate ownership often correlates with:
- •Cost-cutting that reduces staffing ratios
- •Lower investment in staff training and quality improvement
- •Less community accountability than locally-owned facilities
The Silver Lining:
Columbus's quality facilities tend to be nonprofit or faith-based organizations with deep community roots: Worthington Christian Village, Ohio Living Westminster-Thurber, Wesley Glen. These facilities buck the trend and deliver genuine excellence.
Costs & Affordability
Columbus nursing homes cost an average of $315 per day for semi-private rooms, which is 3% above the national average and 6% above the Ohio state average.
| Cost Type | Daily Rate | Monthly Rate | Annual Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Columbus Semi-Private | $315 | $9,589 | $114,975 |
| Columbus Private | $340 | $10,350 | $124,100 |
| Ohio State Average | $297 | $9,030 | $108,405 |
| National Average | $305 | $9,150 | $111,325 |
Columbus vs. Other Ohio Cities
Columbus costs are in line with other major Ohio metros:
- •Cleveland: ~$305/day, similar quality challenges
- •Cincinnati: ~$310/day, slightly better quality distribution
- •Toledo: ~$285/day, lower costs but more limited quality options
Columbus offers middle-ground pricing within Ohio - not the cheapest, not the most expensive. The challenge is that costs are average while quality lags other markets.
What's Included in Columbus Rates?
The daily rate typically includes:
- ✓24/7 skilled nursing care and supervision
- ✓Room (typically semi-private in Columbus), utilities, housekeeping
- ✓Three meals daily plus snacks
- ✓Personal care assistance (bathing, dressing, mobility)
- ✓Social and recreational activities
- ✓Medication administration and management
Additional costs may include: Physical/occupational/speech therapy, specialized memory care, private rooms, and personal items.
Quality Analysis & Star Ratings
Columbus nursing homes average 2.6 stars on Medicare's Five-Star Quality Rating System, below the national average and reflecting significant quality variation across facilities.
Star Rating Distribution
| Rating | Facilities | Percentage |
|---|---|---|
| ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 Stars | 6 | 19% |
| ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4 Stars | 1 | 3% |
| ⭐⭐⭐ 3 Stars | 3 | 10% |
| ⭐⭐ 2 Stars | 16 | 52% |
| ⭐ 1 Star | 4 | 13% |
| Not Yet Rated | 1 | 3% |
Quality Distribution Reality:
52% of Columbus facilities (16 out of 31) are rated just 2 stars. This concentration in mediocrity means families must actively seek out the 7 facilities (23%) with 4-5 stars. Don't settle for average when quality options exist.
What the Star Ratings Mean
Medicare's Five-Star Rating evaluates three key areas:
- •Health Inspections (50% weight): On-site surveys checking compliance with federal health and safety standards
- •Staffing (25% weight): Registered nurse (RN) and total nurse staffing hours per resident per day
- •Quality Measures (25% weight): Clinical outcomes like pressure ulcers, falls, medication management
Columbus's concentration of 2-star facilities suggests widespread challenges across all three rating areas, particularly staffing and health inspections.
Top-Rated Facilities (6 Five-Star Options)
Columbus has 6 five-star nursing homes and 1 four-star facility. Given the market's quality challenges, these 7 facilities should be your primary focus. Here are the top-rated options:
Worthington Christian Village
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Address: 165 Highbluffs Blvd, Worthington, OH
Capacity: 41 beds
Premier continuing care retirement community (CCRC) in affluent Worthington suburb. Boutique facility with exceptional personalized attention. Faith-based but serves all residents. Higher cost reflects premium quality and amenities.
Ohio Living Westminster-Thurber
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Address: 717 Neil Avenue, Columbus, OH
Capacity: 35 beds
Small, high-quality facility near downtown and Ohio State campus. Part of Ohio Living network (nonprofit senior services organization). Close to medical centers and cultural amenities. Excellent staff-to-resident ratio.
Wesley Glen Health Services Corp
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Address: 5155 North High Street, Columbus, OH
Capacity: 56 beds
Faith-based facility on Columbus's north side. Strong community reputation for compassionate care. Good balance of clinical quality and home-like environment. Convenient Clintonville location.
Westerwood Rehabilitation
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Address: 5757 Ponderosa Drive, Columbus, OH
Capacity: 75 beds
Strong rehabilitation focus - excellent for post-hospital recovery. Modern facility with comprehensive therapy services. Westerville location provides suburban setting with easy access to medical services.
Mohun Health Care Center
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Address: 2340 Airport Dr, Columbus, OH
Capacity: 72 beds
Well-established facility with long track record of quality. Good Medicare/Medicaid acceptance. Accessible east side location. Strong medical partnerships for complex care needs.
Highbanks Care Center
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Address: 111 Lazelle Road East, Columbus, OH
Capacity: 56 beds
North Columbus facility with strong quality ratings. Suburban setting near Highbanks Metro Park. Mid-size facility allows personalized attention. Good family visiting environment.
Willow Brook Christian Home
⭐⭐⭐⭐Address: 55 Lazelle Rd, Columbus, OH
Capacity: 50 beds
Faith-based facility near Highbanks Care Center. Christian organization but serves all faiths. Smaller size provides intimate, personalized care. Good backup option if five-star facilities have waitlists.
Important Advice:
Given Columbus's quality distribution, tour ALL 7 of these facilities before considering lower-rated options. Many of these are small (35-56 beds) and may have waitlists, so apply early and get on multiple lists.
Want detailed comparisons?
View complete Columbus nursing home rankings with all 31 facilities, inspection reports, staffing data, and quality metrics.
Columbus Neighborhoods & Areas
Columbus's diverse neighborhoods each offer different advantages for nursing home selection:
Worthington / Dublin (Northwest Suburbs)
Best for: Highest quality care, affluent suburbs
Home to Worthington Christian Village (5-star). Upscale communities with excellent schools, shopping, and dining. Easy access to I-270 outerbelt. Higher costs but best quality concentration.
Clintonville / North Columbus
Best for: Walkable neighborhoods, community feel
Home to Wesley Glen (5-star) and Highbanks Care Center (5-star). Established neighborhoods with tree-lined streets. Close to Ohio State campus and High Street corridor. Good mix of affordability and quality.
Downtown / Short North
Best for: Urban lifestyle, cultural access
Ohio Living Westminster-Thurber (5-star) near downtown. Close to Ohio State Wexner Medical Center, Nationwide Children's Hospital. Urban setting with arts, dining, entertainment. Limited parking for visitors.
Westerville / Northeast Columbus
Best for: Family-friendly suburbs, newer facilities
Home to Westerwood Rehabilitation (5-star). Suburban community with good schools and parks. Easy access to Polaris shopping area and medical offices. More affordable than Worthington/Dublin.
East Columbus / Airport Area
Best for: Accessibility, diverse options
Mohun Health Care Center (5-star) and other facilities. Easy access from I-270 and I-670. Convenient to Port Columbus Airport for out-of-town family. More affordable than northwest suburbs.
Grove City / West Columbus
Best for: Affordability, working-class communities
Southwestern suburbs with lower cost of living. More limited high-quality nursing home options - worth traveling to other parts of Columbus for better facilities. Good highway access via I-71.
Ohio Medicaid & Financial Assistance
At $9,589 per month for semi-private rooms, nursing home care in Columbus represents a significant expense. Understanding payment options is crucial for long-term planning.
Ohio Medicaid Coverage
Ohio Medicaid covers nursing home care for eligible low-income seniors. To qualify:
- •Income limit: $2,829/month for individuals (2025)
- •Asset limit: $2,000 for individuals (excluding home, car, and personal belongings)
- •Medical necessity: Must require nursing facility level of care as determined by PASSPORT assessment
Medicaid Reality in Columbus:
Not all high-quality Columbus facilities accept Medicaid, and those that do often have limited Medicaid beds. Ask specifically about Medicaid acceptance, waitlist times, and any differences in care quality between private-pay and Medicaid residents.
Other Payment Options
Medicare (Limited Coverage)
Medicare covers up to 100 days of skilled nursing care following a qualifying hospital stay (3+ days). First 20 days are fully covered; days 21-100 require copayment ($200/day in 2025). Not for long-term custodial care.
Long-Term Care Insurance
Private insurance policies can cover $3,000-$6,000/month of nursing home costs. Columbus's moderate pricing means policies stretch further than in expensive markets.
Veterans Benefits
Veterans may qualify for Aid & Attendance benefits (up to $2,431/month for couples, $2,050/month for individuals in 2025). Contact the Columbus VA Medical Center at (614) 257-5200 or visit va.gov.
Private Pay Then Medicaid Transition
Many families initially pay out-of-pocket and transition to Medicaid once assets are spent down. Work with a certified Medicaid planner to structure assets legally and maximize eligibility.
Need Help with Medicaid Planning?
Contact the Central Ohio Area Agency on Aging at (614) 645-7877 or visit coaaa.org for free counseling on Medicaid eligibility and application assistance.
How to Choose the Right Columbus Nursing Home
With only 7 facilities rated 4-5 stars (23% of Columbus nursing homes), families must be strategic and selective. Here's a systematic approach:
Step 1: Focus Exclusively on 4-5 Star Facilities
Given Columbus's quality distribution, start and ideally end your search with these 7 facilities:
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Worthington Christian Village (41 beds)
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Ohio Living Westminster-Thurber (35 beds)
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Wesley Glen Health Services (56 beds)
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Westerwood Rehabilitation (75 beds)
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Mohun Health Care Center (72 beds)
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Highbanks Care Center (56 beds)
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐Willow Brook Christian Home (50 beds)
Why This Matters:
With 52% of Columbus facilities rated just 2 stars, there's no reason to consider lower-quality options when seven excellent facilities exist. Tour all seven and get on multiple waitlists if needed.
Step 2: Review Recent Inspection Reports
Even among five-star facilities, check recent surveys:
- •Visit Medicare.gov/care-compare for full inspection reports
- •Check Ohio Department of Health reports for state-specific violations
- •Look for patterns across multiple surveys, not isolated incidents
- •Verify deficiencies were corrected (facilities must submit correction plans)
Step 3: Tour Thoroughly
Schedule tours at multiple facilities. Visit at different times of day and use this checklist:
Columbus Nursing Home Tour Checklist
- ✓ Facility cleanliness and freedom from unpleasant odors
- ✓ Resident appearance, grooming, and engagement levels
- ✓ Staff interactions - respectful, patient, attentive?
- ✓ Actual staff-to-resident ratio during your visit (ask administrator)
- ✓ Response time to call lights (observe for 20-30 minutes)
- ✓ Food quality - ask to sample a meal
- ✓ Activities calendar and actual resident participation
- ✓ Room conditions, size, privacy, maintenance
- ✓ Staff turnover rate - high turnover is a major red flag
- ✓ Medicare vs Medicaid bed availability and policies
- ✓ Speak with current residents and families if possible
- ✓ Trust your gut - does this feel like a place your loved one can thrive?
Step 4: Apply Early and Get on Waitlists
Columbus's best facilities are small (35-75 beds) and often have waitlists:
- •Start your search 3-6 months before you need care if possible
- •Apply to multiple facilities simultaneously - it's free to be on waitlists
- •Stay in touch with facilities monthly to update your status and needs
- •Consider temporary placement in a hospital-based facility while waiting for your top choice
Final Recommendation:
Columbus's nursing home market requires active, informed decision-making. Don't settle for mediocrity when excellent care exists. Tour all seven 4-5 star facilities, apply early, and be willing to wait for quality. Your loved one deserves the best Columbus has to offer.
Ready to Compare Columbus Nursing Homes?
View detailed comparisons, inspection reports, and quality metrics for all 31 Columbus nursing homes.
View Columbus Rankings