Best Nursing Homes in New York (2026 Rankings)

New York Nursing Home Statistics

601

Total Facilities

123

5-Star Facilities

126

1-Star Facilities

Avg Quality Score

How We Rank Facilities

Rankings are based on our composite quality score (0-100), which combines: CMS star ratings (22 pts), staffing quality (20 pts), quality measures (22 pts), compliance history (18 pts), safety records (13 pts), and availability (5 pts). This comprehensive approach goes beyond Medicare's star ratings to provide a more complete picture of care quality.

Last updated: November 16, 2025 | Data source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)

Learn more about evaluating nursing homes:

Understanding Star Ratings State Quality Comparison What to Ask on Tours

THE KNOLLS

55 GRASSLAND ROAD • VALHALLA, NY 10595

Phone: (914)989-7800

B+

Quality Score: 58

CMS Ratings

22.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

HELEN HAYES HOSPITAL R H C F

51 N RT 9W • WEST HAVERSTRAW, NY 10993

Phone: (845)786-4000

B+

Quality Score: 58

CMS Ratings

22.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

JAMES G JOHNSTON MEMORIAL NURSING HOME

285 DEYO HILL ROAD • JOHNSON CITY, NY 13790

Phone: (607)798-7818

B+

Quality Score: 58

CMS Ratings

22.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

JEWISH HOME OF ROCHESTER

2021 WINTON ROAD SOUTH • ROCHESTER, NY 14618

Phone: (585)427-7760

B+

Quality Score: 58

CMS Ratings

22.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

ST JOSEPHS PLACE

160 EAST MAIN STREET • PORT JERVIS, NY 12771

Phone: (845)856-5351

B+

Quality Score: 58

CMS Ratings

22.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

BEECHWOOD HOMES

2235 MILLERSPORT HIGHWAY • GETZVILLE, NY 14068

Phone: (716)810-7000

B+

Quality Score: 57

CMS Ratings

21.1/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

JOHN T MATHER MEMORIAL HOSP T C U

75 NORTH COUNTRY ROAD • PORT JEFFERSON, NY 11777

Phone: (631)473-1320

B+

Quality Score: 57

CMS Ratings

20.9/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

KENDAL ON HUDSON

ONE KENDAL WAY • SLEEPY HOLLOW, NY 10591

Phone: (914)922-1000

B+

Quality Score: 57

CMS Ratings

20.9/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

COLER REHABILITATION AND NURSING CARE CENTER

900 MAIN ST • ROOSEVELT ISLAND, NY 10044

Phone: (212)848-6000

B+

Quality Score: 57

CMS Ratings

20.9/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#10

CHAPIN HOME FOR THE AGING

165 01 CHAPIN PARKWAY • JAMAICA, NY 11432

Phone: (718)739-2523

B+

Quality Score: 56

CMS Ratings

20.5/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#11

N Y S VETERANS HOME

4211 STATE HIGHWAY 220 • OXFORD, NY 13830

Phone: (607)843-3100

B+

Quality Score: 56

CMS Ratings

20.2/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#12

OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE

5285 LEWISTON ROAD • LEWISTON, NY 14092

Phone: (716)298-2900

B+

Quality Score: 56

CMS Ratings

20.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#13

BROTHERS OF MERCY NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER

10570 BERGTOLD ROAD • CLARENCE, NY 14031

Phone: (716)759-6985

B+

Quality Score: 56

CMS Ratings

20.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#14

UNITED HEBREW GERIATRIC CENTER

391 PELHAM ROAD • NEW ROCHELLE, NY 10805

Phone: (914)632-2804

B+

Quality Score: 56

CMS Ratings

20.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#15

ST MARGARETS CENTER

27 HACKETT BLVD • ALBANY, NY 12208

Phone: (518)591-3300

B+

Quality Score: 56

CMS Ratings

19.8/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#16

ACADIA CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION

1146 WOODCREST AVENUE • RIVERHEAD, NY 11901

Phone: (631)727-7744

B+

Quality Score: 55

CMS Ratings

19.1/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#17

IRA DAVENPORT MEMORIAL HOSPITAL S N F/ H R F

7571 STATE ROUTE 54 • BATH, NY 14810

Phone: (607)776-8500

B+

Quality Score: 55

CMS Ratings

19.1/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#18

DUNKIRK REHABILITATION & NURSING CENTER

447 449 LAKE SHORE DRIVE WEST • DUNKIRK, NY 14048

Phone: (716)366-6710

B+

Quality Score: 55

CMS Ratings

21.1/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

6.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#19

GOOD SAMARITAN NURSING AND REHABILITATION CARE CTR

101 ELM ST • SAYVILLE, NY 11782

Phone: (631)244-2400

Quality Score: 55

CMS Ratings

18.9/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

10.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#20

METHODIST HOME FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION

4499 MANHATTAN COLLEGE PARKWAY • BRONX, NY 10471

Phone: (718)548-5100

Quality Score: 54

CMS Ratings

20.5/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

6.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#21

SHORE VIEW NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER

2865 BRIGHTON 3RD STREET • BROOKLYN, NY 11235

Phone: (718)891-4400

Quality Score: 54

CMS Ratings

20.2/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

6.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#22

THE PLAZA REHAB AND NURSING CENTER

100 WEST KINGSBRIDGE ROAD • BRONX, NY 10468

Phone: (718)410-1500

Quality Score: 54

CMS Ratings

20.2/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

6.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#23

FOX RUN AT ORCHARD PARK

ONE FOX RUN LANE • ORCHARD PARK, NY 14127

Phone: (716)662-5001

Quality Score: 54

CMS Ratings

20.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

6.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#24

DR SUSAN SMITH MCKINNEY NURSING AND REHAB CENTER

594 ALBANY AVENUE • BROOKLYN, NY 11203

Phone: (718)245-7000

Quality Score: 54

CMS Ratings

22.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

2.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

#25

MERCY HOSPITAL SKILLED NURSING FACILITY

55 MELROY AVENUE • LACKAWANNA, NY 14218

Phone: (716)819-5300

Quality Score: 54

CMS Ratings

22.0/22

Staffing

0.0/20

Quality

0.0/22

Compliance

18.0/18

Safety

13.0/13

Availability

2.0/10

View Full Details →

CMS Rating:

More Resources for New York

New York Overview

View state-level statistics, regulations, and general information about nursing homes in New York.

Search by City

Find nursing homes in specific cities across New York with our advanced search tool.

← View All States